Software & Apps

GTA 6 Review Bombing: Why User Scores Clash With a 99/100 Metacritic Rating

TETechPulse Team8 views
GTA 6 Review Bombing: Why User Scores Clash With a 99/100 Metacritic Rating

TL;DR: GTA 6 holds a 99/100 Metacritic critic score and a 99% OpenCritic score, while Metacritic's open user score fell as low as 3.7/10 before recovering toward 5.6. Verified-purchase ratings on the PlayStation and Xbox stores sit near 4.9/5. The gap is part real criticism, part review bombing.

Two numbers describe GTA 6's reception, and they point in opposite directions. Critics call it one of the best games ever made. A large group of Metacritic users spent launch week pushing its score toward the bottom of the scale.

Both numbers are real. Neither one, on its own, tells you what the game is like.

The scores, side by side

  • Metacritic critic score: 99/100, based on 152 PS5 reviews and 14 Xbox reviews.
  • OpenCritic: 99%, with 99% of critics recommending the game across 90 reviews.
  • Metacritic user score: as low as 3.7/10 the day after release, recovering to roughly 5.6/10 by 21 November.
  • PlayStation Store: about 4.84/5 from roughly 170,000 ratings.
  • Xbox Store: about 4.9/5.

A 99 critic score is almost unheard of. A 3.7 user score is the kind of number usually reserved for broken launches. Both belonging to the same game is not a contradiction — it is a lesson in how different review systems work.

What players are actually complaining about

The complaints are not imaginary. Across reviews, forums and social posts, the same issues keep coming up:

  • The 30 FPS cap. GTA 6 runs at 30 frames per second on both PS5 and Xbox Series X|S, and there is no confirmed 60 FPS performance mode. For players used to high frame rates, this is the single biggest technical disappointment.
  • Aiming and controls. Reviewers and players have both criticised the shooting and aiming feel. It is the kind of thing that can be patched, but at launch it is a real friction point.
  • Features missing from earlier GTA games. Long-time fans expected the series to build on everything GTA V and GTA IV offered, and some systems and activities are not present at launch.
  • Special-edition and physical-copy frustration. Some content is tied to special editions, and some boxed copies reportedly contain download codes rather than discs. Both decisions annoyed buyers.
  • Console loyalty. Big exclusivity-adjacent launches always attract platform-war voting, and GTA 6 is no exception.

Those are legitimate topics for criticism. A low score is not automatically review bombing just because the game is popular.

What review bombing is

Review bombing is a coordinated effort to push a product's user score down, usually to send a message rather than to describe the product. The mechanics are simple: a user score is an average, and on an open platform anyone can create an account and leave a 0/10 or a 10/10 without proving they bought or played the game.

That makes open user scores easy to distort in both directions. A group that wants to punish a publisher can drag the average down, and a group that wants to defend the game can push it back up. The result is a number that reflects a campaign more than a player experience.

Verified-purchase scores tell a different story

The PlayStation Store and Xbox Store only allow ratings from accounts tied to a purchase. Those scores are much higher: about 4.84/5 on PlayStation from roughly 170,000 ratings, and about 4.9/5 on Xbox.

That does not mean the game is flawless. It means people who actually bought and played it are, on average, satisfied. Store ratings have their own biases — refunds, expectations and the fact that unhappy players sometimes skip rating — but they are a useful counterweight to an open score that can be voted on by anyone.

Can the criticism and the celebration both be true?

Yes. This is the part most arguments online miss. A game can be a critical masterpiece and still have a frame-rate cap that bothers people. It can have a 99 critic score and still ship with aiming that feels wrong to some players. It can break sales records and still frustrate buyers who opened a box expecting a disc.

The honest reading is that GTA 6 is an exceptional piece of craft with real technical and design complaints, and that the user score at its lowest was not a measurement of those complaints. It was a campaign on top of them.

How to read scores sensibly

  • Critic scores measure craft and technical execution from people who finished the game before launch week. They are useful for “is this well made?”
  • Open user scores measure sentiment, and sentiment can be organised. They are useful for “what is the conversation?”, not “is this good?”
  • Verified-purchase scores measure buyer satisfaction with a large sample. They are the best single number for “will I regret buying this?”
  • Long-form reviews and gameplay videos answer the questions scores cannot: does the frame rate bother you, does the aiming click, does the story land.

Bottom line

GTA 6's critic scores say it is one of the best-reviewed games ever made. Its user score at launch says a lot of people were angry about the 30 FPS cap, the controls, edition content and platform politics — and that some of that anger was organised. Verified buyers are overwhelmingly positive. If you are deciding whether to buy, trust the verified ratings and your own tolerance for 30 FPS, not the war in the user-score section.

How did this story feel?

Be the first to react

AI assistance. This article was researched and drafted with AI tools and reviewed by our editorial team before publication. We link to sources at the end of every article so you can verify the claims. If you spot an error, please let us know.

Recommended gear

Related picks for this guide

More on Amazon ↗

Affiliate links: we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

More on #GTA 6

Weekly tech brief

The tech stories worth your time, every Sunday.

One short email with the most useful guides and gadget picks from the week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Written by

TechPulse Team

The TechPulse editorial team publishes clear, practical technology guides. Every article is original and written to be understood — not just skimmed. Read our editorial policy.

Comments (0)

?

Be kind. No account needed.

No comments yet — start the conversation!

Keep reading

GTA 6 Review Bombing: Why User Scores Clash With a 99/100 Metacritic Rating | TechPulse